Sep
27
2009
Would you know world class if you saw it?
Author: AdrianThe Washington Post arranged for Joshua Bell, one of the world’s finest classical musicians, to busk incognito in a metro station. They wanted to know if the average commuter would spot musical ‘greatness’ if they saw it unannounced. They called it an “experiment in context, perception and priorities.” What do you think happened?
Would you know world class if you saw it?
For 43 minutes, the internationally acclaimed virtuoso performed six classical pieces, “some of the most elegant music ever written on one of the most valuable violins ever made.”
1,097 people passed by, few stopped to appreciate the music and 27 people gave a total of $32.
What does this tell us? On this occasion, in a ‘banal setting at an inconvenient time’ beauty did not transcend. It seems that context is important.
We would perhaps like to think that we would know world class if we saw it, but the truth is that without a context great work can be hard to appreciate.
We see this is other walks of life too: art treasures can be lost in attics; in many fields the greats are only discovered years after their deaths; different stores retail the same product at vastly different prices.
For aspiring creatives this holds a lesson; it can be hard to appreciate the quality of our own work as we tend to see it in a particular ‘personal’ context. Familiarity can allow us to overlook the quality of our work and, conversely, out intentions can cause us to underestimate its flaws.
This story also instructs us not to believe the feedback we receive. Joshua Bell was used to reverential audiences but was ignored in the subway. His work was the same in both situations; it was the context that was different.
Pay Attention
The context on this occasion was the daily commute. People do not expect to see a world class musician performing as a busker and so they tended to overlook it when it actually happened. The other point is that their minds were probably elsewhere; already in work, or perhaps still in bed, or on some other daydream.
If we are able to miss something of this quality then what else do we miss?
Without the ability to pay attention we can miss so much that the world has to offer. And if we are in the business of creating art we might benefit from noticing what is going on around us.
The daily commute can train us to focus inward, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Every time a child walked past he or she tried to stop and watch (and the parent hurried the child along). Is this because the children are more open to having new experiences?
As a general rule we should remember that we need to be present in order to appreciate life and similarly we need to bepresent to create art. We do not know when the next world class performance will be staged right before our eyes.